Raheem Kassam of Student Rights

Raheem Kassam of Student Rights

Twitter spat erupts between “anti-extremism” experts

Posted by

A Twitter spat yesterday between so-called anti-extremism experts ended up with one of them being branded an “anti-Muslim fraud”, writes Laura Stuart.

Raheem Kassam, from the right-wing organisation Student Rights, was accused of being “anti-Muslim” and a “fraud” by his fellow “anti-extremism” experts.

His main accuser was Hasan Afzal, of British Muslims for Israel, following an article in The Commentator titled: “Tensions high in British town after Muslim youths attack white girls.” 

The headline itself would appear to effectively incite English Defence League members to violence against Muslims. Afzal went on to demand that an article previously written by him be removed from The Commentator website which Kassam is the Executive Editor of.

The spat then escalated into Afzal calling Kassam “a fraud and an embarrassment”. Another “extremism expert” Shiraz Maher condemned the article for lack of context and also accused Kassam of “getting off on bad language and threats”. In general, there was a fair amount of foul language and accusations exchanged in the spat which took place.

Raheem Kassam and the organization he works for, Student Rights, had their dubious research and reporting methods exposed by Hilary Aked recently in the Huffington Post.

In recent years so-called Muslim extremism experts have been quoting from talks by Islamic scholars and using them out of context to spread fear and alarm. This has heaped pressure on venue providers and hosts to close down events.

Most universities and venue providers are quite able to make the decision to allow Muslim events to go ahead based on police advice but what has often transpired in the past is that groups such as the EDL, Casuals United and others pick up those articles and go on to make threats to protest at the venues themselves.

The link between Student Rights mobilizing the EDL, Casuals United and other anti-Muslim groups is something that I have written about in the past. The relationship appears to be one that both are comfortable with, one side doing the inciting on the net and the other making the threats.

The irony of this particular Twitter spat between Afzal and Kassam is that both of them share so much in common, i.e. both claim to be Muslim “extremism experts”, both have websites involved in targeting Muslim clerics and speaker’s events, claiming to stand for “liberal values” and “free speech” whilst openly denying Muslims the benefit of either. And above all both are avid supporters of Israel.

The connection between anti-Muslim bigotry, anti-Muslim extremism websites, Islamophobia and pro-Israeli advocacy is definitely something that needs to be further investigated, examined and exposed.

The final word on the Twitter spat came from Raheem Kassam, who denies all the accusations against him. He promised to expose Hasan Afzal’s connections to the EDL in an article on The Commentator today and arranged for a private meeting with Maher.

The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of the 5 Pillarz editorial board


Following the publication of this article Raheem Kassam made the following comments (a full version of which can be seen below in the comments section).

“I am writing to you following the publication of a factually inaccurate article on your pages… The news item on The Commentator to which you refer, entitled ‘Tensions high in British town after Muslim youths attack white girls’ is not authored by me. There is nothing to suggest such on the website. The article was a collaboration between Commentator contributors and carries the by-line ‘The Commentator.’

“You refer to a ‘link’ between Student Rights, the EDL and Casuals United. No such link exists. Student Rights has repeatedly condemned EDL and Casuals United, and therefore your comment that ‘the relationship appears to be one that both are comfortable with’ is predicated on a falsehood and demonstrably untrue.”

Laura Stuart



Facebook Comments


Video Player

The lamest thing British Muslims have ever done? Discuss…

British Muslims – some quite prominent – take part in a music video which shows that Muslims can be happy. Warm-hearted affirmation of pos

Video: Nine-month old boy accused of planning murder in Pakistan

A 9-month old boy has appeared in court in Pakistan on charges of planning a murder, threatening police and interfering in state affairs. Muhammad Mos

Dilly’s Desk: Vlog episode 1 – Turkey, Muslim Brotherhood and David Cameron

In the first video edition of Dilly’s Desk, the deputy editor of 5Pillarz shares his thoughts on the week’s biggest news. Filmed in my fri

Dr Aafia Siddiqui speaking on “Women in Islam” in 1991

A rare video of Dr Aafia Siddiqui speaking on “Women in Islam” in Houston, US, in 1991. In March 2003, Aafia Siddiqui and her three childr

Imagine if London was occupied

Thought-provoking video about Israeli checkpoints in occupied Palestine. Following a road accident a man attempts to take a woman to hospital to get h

Prevent officers attend digital transmitter launch at Birmingham Central Mosque

Officers from the West Midlands Counter Terrorism Unit’s Prevent team were among the “guests” for the launch of a new hi-tech digita

Tony Benn was “greatest leader this country never had”

George Galloway MP looks back at the life of Tony Benn, who died on Friday, and argues that he would have been one of Britain’s greatest prime m

Palestinians urge opening of Rafah border

Gaza resident Noor Harazeen makes an appeal for the world to help relieve the economic and military siege of Gaza imposed on the Palestinians by Israe

Allegiance Clothing Official Trailer

A new Islamic designer clothing brand has launched with a strong emphasis on urban street culture. Rapper and Muslim convert, Brother Jalaal features


When aggressive “Black Israelites” lose a debate

In this video Ali Dawah of The Da’wow Project discusses with a group of Black Israelites in Trafalgar Square, London. The group which call thems

John Fontain gives dawah to rapper Game and his crew

In this exclusive video, Muslim convert John Fontain invites rapper Game and his crew to Islam when they visited Manchester. Whilst the Game refused t


Exclusive Interview – The Life Of Nouman Ali Khan

Nouman Ali Khan founded the Bayyinah institute for Arabic and Quranic studies in 2005. Ustadh Nouman is an expert on the linguistic miracle of the Hol

Moazzam Begg’s speech on Muslim unity

This video is the last talk Moazzam Begg delivered before his arrest last month. The lecture specifically addresses the issue of Muslim unity and the

Jabhat al-Nusra release 16 Greek Orthodox nuns in prisoner swap

A Syrian rebel faction has released Greek Orthodox nuns in a rare prisoner exchange with the government of Bashar al-Assad. Jabhat al-Nusra released 1

Why is Moazzam Begg being criminalised? Did he know too much?

Moazzam Begg, the former Guantanamo Bay detainee and director of advocacy group CAGE, was one of four people arrested this morning on suspicion of Syr

London Dawah Movement responds to Katy Perry’s “Dark Horse” video

London Dawah Movement responds to Katy Perry’s controversial song “Dark Horse” where the name of Allah (swt) in Arabic is burned. In

Debate – Do we have the right to offend?

Mohammed Shafiq of Ramadhan Foundation presents Debate Night on Ummah Channel on the topic of “Do we have the right to offend?” Panellists

London Dawah Movement responds to Richard Littlejohn’s article

London Dawah Movement speaks to the British public in response to an article published in the Daily Mail by columnist Richard Littlejohn on a Muslim f

Rival groups clash in Whitechapel during Bangladeshi memorial day

Violent clashes erupted at Altab Ali Park in East London between rival groups after Bangladeshi Martyrs Day. Metal barricades were used as improvised

Video: Scottish Muslim minister Humza Yousaf racially abused

Video has emerged showing a Muslim member of the Scottish Parliament being racially abused as he sold the Big Issue in Glasgow city centre. Humza Yous

Central African Republic: On the brink of genocide

Unabated violence between Christians and Muslims has plagued the Central African Republic since a coup by Seleka fighters to overthrow former presiden

Dr Yasir Qadhi – World War One and the break up of the Khilafah

In this lecture, Dr Yasir Qadhi goes over the historical events prior to the build up of World War One, how the Ottoman Caliphate was drawn into the G

Video posted online of British suicide bomber Abdul Majeed Majid

A video has been posted online showing British man Abdul Waheed Majid, who is thought to have carried out a suicide bombing in Syria. The 41-year-old,

Julian Assange: Surveillance of Muslims will soon affect rest of population

Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, who’s currently under effective self-imposed house arrest in the Ecuadorian embassy in London, says state surv

Ducks attracted by the recitation of the Quran

This video shows a Muslim boy reciting the Quran to a raft of ducks who come close to him but move away from him when he stops reciting. The young boy